Showing posts with label keg bitter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label keg bitter. Show all posts

Saturday, 31 August 2024

Let's Brew - 1970 Watneys Red Barrel

A couple of days ago someone asked me if I'd ever published a recipe of Watneys Red Barrel. I knew I'd written one and assumed that I'd posted it at some point. It turns out that I hadn't. So here you go.

I couldn’t miss this iconic beer. Even if it’s iconic for all the wrong reasons. Gaining a reputation as the classic terrible beer. But was it intrinsically awful?

The recipe doesn’t look much different to other Bitters of the day. It’s over 90% malt, which most of its rivals weren’t. And it’s only malt and sugar. There are no adjuncts. There was a little Dixon’s enzymic malt, which I’ve replaced with more base malt.

The hopping looks fine, too: Fuggles for bittering and Goldings for aroma. And enough to leave a decent degree of bitterness. Dry-hopped, too. Though that was with some form of hop concentrate.

Overall, it looks like a pretty decent beer. That’s before it was pasteurised. Derek Prentice told me that the Truman’s beers of this period always tasted stale because of the heavy pasteurisation. Perhaps that was also the case with Red Barrel. 

1970 Watneys Red Barrel
pale malt 7.50 lb 87.41%
crystal malt 60 L 0.33 lb 3.85%
No. 3 invert sugar 0.50 lb 5.83%
malt extract 0.25 lb 2.91%
Fuggles 105 min 1.75 oz
Goldings 15 min 0.75 oz
Goldings dry hops 0.125 oz
OG 1039.2
FG 1006
ABV 4.39
Apparent attenuation 84.69%
IBU 32
SRM 8
Mash at 158º F
Sparge at 175º F
Boil time 75 minutes
pitching temp 60º F
Yeast WLP023 Burton Ale


Sunday, 10 March 2024

Cask vs Keg Best Bitter in 1976

Another set of cask and keg Bitters. This time, the stronger examples.

This time, there's no difference at all in the average value for money between cask and keg. Though the cask average is distorted by the spectacularly poor value of Watney Fined Bitter. A beer which was 4.5p per pint more expensive than the second dearest, Charles Wells Fargo. A beer which was considerably stronger.

Fined Bitter was a bit of a funny beer. It was the first cask beer bearing the Watney name for quite a while. As they didn't have casks, it was served from a modified keg. Based on the gravity, it looks like a cask version of Watney Special Bitter. I had it a couple of times and wasn't particularly impressed. Though that might have been down to poor cellarmanship. As Watney landlords mostly wouldn't have any experience of looking after cask beer.

A sign that keg and cask prices were levelling out is provided by Draught Bass and Worthington E. I'm pretty sure they were just cask and keg versions of the same beer. And you can see that the price of the two is identical: 25p.

That's all I can think of for now.

Cask Best Bitter in 1976
Brewer Beer Price º gravity per p OG
Charles Wells Draught Fargo 28 1.82 1051
Robinson Best Bitter Ale 24 1.75 1042
Courage Director's Bitter 27 1.74 1047
Devenish (Redruth) Cornish Best Bitter 26 1.63 1042.5
Bass Draught Bass 25 1.60 1040
Watney Fined Bitter 32.5 1.36 1044.2
  Average 27.1 1.65 1044.5
Source:
Sunday Mirror - Sunday 01 August 1976, page 17.

 

Keg Best Bitter in 1976
Brewer Beer Price º gravity per p OG
Tetley Imperial 24 1.75 1042
Usher (Edinburgh) Double Amber 26 1.65 1043
Bass Worthington E 25 1.60 1040
Charles Wells Noggin 25 1.60 1040
  Average 25 1.65 1041.3
Source:
Sunday Mirror - Sunday 01 August 1976, page 17.

 

Friday, 8 March 2024

Cask vs Keg Ordinary Bitter in 1976

Just a short numbery post today. One I wrote a couple of weeks ago to cover now, when I'm in Brazil. Having fun, I hope.

Lots of numbers and not much analysis. Just a quick comparison of typical cask and keg Ordinary Bitters.

What you're seeing here is keg beer move into the mainstream. The beers here aren't the first generation of specifically keg beers. Which were mostly Best Bitters. Or, at least, claiming to be. Some of the beers here, such as Tetley, are just a brewery-conditioned version of their cask Bitter.

That might explain why there's so little difference in price between the two. On average, about half a p. Not much at all, really.

Enough burbling on for today. I've important trip preparations to get on with. 

Cask Ordinary Bitter in 1976
Brewer Beer Price per pint (p) º gravity per p OG
Hardy & Hanson Best Bitter 20 1.95 1039
Banks Bitter 22 1.77 1039
Charles Wells Draught IPA 23 1.57 1036
Tetley Bitter 23 1.54 1035.5
Wem Best Bitter 24 1.54 1037
Burtonwood Best Bitter 23 1.52 1035
Jennings Best Bitter 23 1.52 1035
Whitbread (Fremlins) Trophy 25 1.46 1036.5
  Average 22.9 1.61 1036.6
Source:
Sunday Mirror - Sunday 01 August 1976, page 17.

Keg Ordinary Bitter in 1976
Brewer Beer Price º gravity per p OG
Fullers Bitter 21 1.67 1035
Matthew Brown Heritage 24 1.63 1039
Border Bitter 22 1.59 1035
Courage (Reading) Tavern 24 1.58 1038
Tetley Drum Bitter 23 1.54 1035.5
St. Austell Extra 24 1.54 1037
Whitbread (London) Trophy 24 1.48 1035.5
Alloa Diamond Heavy 25 1.45 1036.2
  Average 23.4 1.56 1036.4
Source:
Sunday Mirror - Sunday 01 August 1976, page 17.


Monday, 4 March 2024

The birth of Keg

The Brewers' Guardian is a gift that just keeps giving. I'm only halfway through 1970 and it's had articles - or even whole features - on exactly the topics I wanted either more information or references. As well as subjects I didn't know I needed to know more about. Like continuous fermentation.

Then I come across an article that references the title of my book on the 1970s: Evolution of the British keg system.

It kicks off with a bit of history. Some of it a little dodgy:

Mr Davidson continued with a brief look at the progress of the U.K. brewing industry over the past 100 years. Facts and figures given in this outline showed that from over 5,000 individual brewers in 1870, there are now seven large brewing groups and approximately 100 smaller and medium sized independent breweries. A great reduction in the number of public houses had taken place in the same period. Other changes had been alterations in the specific gravities of beers often averaging 1100º prior to 1870, these now averaged between 1030º and 1040º. There had also been a transition from naturally conditioned beer in wooden container (with fining taking place in the public house) to beer chilled and filtered in the brewery.
Brewers' Guardian, Volume 99, May 1970, page 68.

That 1100º is way off. Average OG in 1870 was more like half that. Then he mentions evil keg replacing proper beer. The bastard.

He continues with a justification for keg. And how this cancer started.

"With bottled beer in widespread use by the mid 1930’s, the next natural logical development,” Mr. Davidson went on, "was bright beer in cask.”

"It can be said that the first step towards the keg system as we know it today was taken by Watneys, who purchased in 1929 a Bergendorfer bulk pasteuriser, which had been exhibited that year. With this pasteuriser it was hoped to overcome problems of conservation of beer exported to the Far East. In 1930 Watneys were the first to export a filtered, pasteurised beer, known as Watney Container Bitter, in stainless steel five-gallon drums.

In the following two to three years the brewery launched this container beer throughout the U.K., using stainless steel drums with a Baines neck. You will be familiar with this neck, which became virtually standard throughout the U.K. To seal the container, a snap valve was used and dispensing was by means of a Barnes syphon tube and CO2. Watneys continued to use this system until as late as 1959.
Brewers' Guardian, Volume 99, May 1970, page 68.

I'm hoping this bit of history is better. Mr Davidson was sales director, Grundygroup Export Ltd., manufacturers of things like kegs. And, er Grundy tanks. Start of the 1930s. That's earlier than keg is normally supposed to have started its deadly rise. End of the decade is usually quoted. Interesting that Keg Bitter started as an export beer. That sort of makes sense.

I'm just not sure how much I should trust a salesman. I'd be more committed to it if it were coming from a brewer at Watney. Rather than the man selling them kegs. Still, it was in the Brewers' Guardian. Let's see if anyone from Watney commented on the article in a later edition.

Wednesday, 13 December 2023

Let's Brew Wednesday - 1982 Eldridge Pope Crystal

A lovely, watery keg Bitter from my 1970s book.  I'm taking the tiotle quite literally.

The other half of the Goldie parti-gyle was Crystal. Which was their Light Ale when bottled, but was also available as a keg Bitter. The brew house name was BAK (Bottling AK).

The brewery described it thus:

"Crystal Bitter - A direct descendent of Dorchester’s Original Ale - the bitter with the body and the good value pint."

For that, I read: cheap and watery. Which is a fair enough description of a beer that’s barely 3% ABV. It looks very much like a Boy’s Bitter – a low-gravity Pale Ale which in the Southwest took the place of Mild Ale.

Speaking of which, the Eldridge Pope promotional brochure also lists a keg Dark Mild with about the same OG. I’d put money on it being Crystal with added caramel.

There’s some crystal here, which was only present in the second mash tun’ Leaving the colour almost as dark as Goldie, despite its much lower strength. Its OG not much lower than the FG of Goldie.

The usual hops of three English and one Styrian. 

1982 Eldridge Pope Crystal
pale malt 6.00 lb 85.71%
crystal malt 60 L 0.50 lb 7.14%
wheat flour 0.50 lb 7.14%
Styrian Goldings 75 min 0.50 oz
Fuggles 60 min 0.75 oz
Goldings 30 min 0.50 oz
OG 1030
FG 1006
ABV 3.18
Apparent attenuation 80.00%
IBU 25
SRM 6
Mash at 153º F
Sparge at 165º F
Boil time 75 minutes
pitching temp 62.5º F
Yeast WLP099 Super High Gravity Thomas Hardy


Saturday, 14 October 2023

Let's Brew - 1969 Truman Ben Truman

As a change from recipes vainly trying to push my published books, here's a recipe from one that isn't finished yet, "Keg!". If you're reading this post in six months' time, please buy a copy.

P1 B was a Burton Pale Ale with a long pedigree, having been brewed since 1877. It was Truman’s equivalent of Bass Red Triangle and, originally, was exclusively a bottled beer. Sometime in the late 1950s and early 1960s it was introduced in keg form, playing the role of Truman’s premium Keg Bitter.

I’m not sure why they were brewing it on Brick Lane while their Burton brewery was still open. Maybe they were just preparing for closure by shifting some brands to London.

The recipe is very different from the other Pale Ales. There’s no crystal malt and no flaked barley. But, in addition to the cane sugar, there was another sugar called WSI.

There were two types of Kent hops from the 1968 harvest, plus another of English hops pf unspecified vintage. The hopping is very light at just 4 lbs per quarter (336 lbs) of malt. That’s the same as the Mild and 1.4 lbs per quarter less than in the other Pale Ales.

I remember the shiny font for this beer, with a portrait of Ben, just like on the label. Being totally brainwashed by the Trots at CAMRA  HQ, I never foe a second considered trying it.

1969 Truman Ben Truman
pale malt 9.25 lb 86.05%
pearl barley 1.00 lb 9.30%
cane sugar 0.50 lb 4.65%
Fuggles 90 mins 0.50 oz
Fuggles 60 mins 0.50 oz
Fuggles 30 mins 0.50 oz
OG 1047
FG 1010
ABV 4.89
Apparent attenuation 78.72%
IBU 18
SRM 4
Mash at 153º F
Sparge at 170º F
Boil time 90 minutes
pitching temp 64º F
Yeast Wyeast 1099 Whitbread ale

 

You could always buy some of my older books. I guarantee they are dead good.


 

Sunday, 9 April 2023

Looking back (part seven): Draught Bitter prices in 1972

After looking at draught Mild the next logical step is to take a gander at Bitter. King of the public bar, at the time.

I'm using the same Daily Mirror article as a source. It's hard to convey just how secret beer strengths were in the past. That's why brewers like Whitbread spent so much effort analysing their rivals' beers. It was the only way of finding out how strong they were. For ordinary drinker? Well, it was just bad luck. Short of analysing beers yourself, you could only guess.

Did brewers take advantage of their customers' ignorance? Of course they fucking did. In the table their are beers called "Best Bitter" with gravities that are very much ordinary. I'd expect a Best to be at least 1040º and 4% ABV.

I drank far fewer of the Bitters than the Milds. Just because I was essentially a Mild drinker. Bathams, Vaux Sampson, Adnams, Courage Best, Theakson and Jennings are the only ones I'm pretty certain that I tried. It was, after all, a very long time ago.

There was a considerable difference in value for money. Three Tuns Bitter was 55% better value than Truman Titan, in terms of gravity. Irinic as Three Tuns was a homebrew pub and so one of the smallest breweries in the country. Blue Anchor, another homebrew house, is third in terms of value for money. And at number two is Bathams, a brewery with just a handful of pubs.

This time the worst value isn't momopolised by Big Six breweries. True, there a lot of them there. This time, eleven of the twelve worst value were keg beers. The only exception being the watery Devenish Bitter, which was a mere 2.7% ABV.

In general, keg Bitter was 1p per pint more expensive than the cask version. You can see this clearly in the table where both are represented. Devenish, for example has Bitter at 11.5p and Saxon, which looks like the same beer kegged, was 12,5p. Greenall Whitley have Bitter at 13p and Festival at 15p. Again, they look like the same beer. Hall & Woodhouse: Badger Best 13p and Forum 14p.

Note that keg beers tended to be named, while cask versions were often simply called Bitter or Best Bitter. 

Draught Bitter prices in 1972
Brewer Beer Price per pint (p) º gravity per p % ABV per p OG FG ABV App. Atten-uation
Three Tuns Bitter 12 3.42 0.35 1041 1008.7 4.20 78.78%
Batham Bitter 13 3.32 0.36 1043.2 1007.1 4.70 83.56%
Blue Anchor Spingo 16 3.24 0.26 1051.9 1019.4 4.20 62.62%
Vaux & Co Sampson 13 3.17 0.30 1041.2 1011.1 3.90 73.06%
Hall & Woodhouse Badger Best 13 3.12 0.31 1040.5 1009.7 4.00 76.05%
Courage Best Bitter 13 3.02 0.32 1039.3 1007.8 4.10 80.15%
Adnam Best Bitter 12 3.02 0.29 1036.2 1009.2 3.50 74.59%
Blue Anchor Ordinary 12 2.98 0.23 1035.8 1014.1 2.80 60.61%
Hall & Woodhouse Forum 14 2.92 0.28 1040.9 1010.8 3.90 73.59%
Banks Bitter 13 2.91 0.29 1037.8 1009.3 3.80 75.40%
Watney Special 12.5 2.90 0.27 1036.2 1010 3.40 72.38%
Jennings Castle 12 2.87 0.31 1034.4 1006 3.70 82.56%
Theakston Best Bitter 13 2.83 0.28 1036.8 1009.1 3.60 75.27%
Vaux & Co Gold Tankard 14 2.81 0.26 1039.4 1011.6 3.60 70.56%
Ind Coope Best Bitter 13 2.81 0.26 1036.5 1010.3 3.40 71.78%
Young & Co Ordinary Bitter 13 2.73 0.27 1035.5 1008.5 3.50 76.06%
Greenall Whitley Bitter 13 2.72 0.30 1035.4 1005.4 3.90 84.75%
Whitbread Trophy 13 2.70 0.28 1035.1 1006.6 3.70 81.20%
Ind Coope Double Diamond 14 2.69 0.24 1037.6 1011.4 3.40 69.68%
Courage  Tavern 14 2.66 0.26 1037.3 1008.8 3.70 76.41%
Watney Red 14 2.66 0.26 1037.2 1009.5 3.60 74.46%
Greene King King Keg 14 2.64 0.23 1037 1008.5 3.20 77.03%
Whitbread Tankard 14.5 2.59 0.27 1037.6 1007.6 3.90 79.79%
Devenish Bitter 11.5 2.57 0.23 1029.6 1008.8 2.70 70.27%
Younger, Wm. Tartan 14 2.56 0.26 1035.9 1007.4 3.70 79.39%
Devenish Saxon 12.5 2.47 0.22 1030.9 1010 2.70 67.64%
Bass, Burton Worthington E 15.5 2.44 0.26 1037.8 1007.1 4.00 81.22%
Greenall Whitley Festival 15 2.40 0.24 1036 1008.3 3.60 76.94%
Truman Special 15 2.38 0.26 1035.7 1005.7 3.90 84.03%
Truman Titan 16 2.28 0.25 1036.5 1005.8 4.00 84.11%
Average   13.5 2.79 0.27 1037.5 1009.1 3.68 75.80%
Source:
Daily Mirror July 10th 1972, page 15


Saturday, 20 June 2020

Let's Brew - 1972 Watneys Red

A fun recipe today: the successor to Red Barrel, Watneys Red.

I can remember the advertising campaign when it launched. All this faux-communist stuff. It was launched in 1971. Not the best timing, as it was just before the cask revival. Wikipedia says it was just a rebranding of Red Barrel. I don’t buy that. The recipe and the OG are pretty different. It looks like a new beer to me.

I’ll be honest with you. I’m a bit light on details for this beer. The Watney Mann Quality Control manual lists the ingredients and the OG and FG I got from an analysis in the Whitbread Gravity Book.

The sugar Is listed as something called Fermax. No idea what that is, so I’ve substituted No.2 invert. I’ve no idea how close that is. But, the colour of the finished beer came out right so it can’t be that far wide of the mark.

As with Red Barrel, you’ll need to process the buggery out of it if you want to go for full authenticity. And preferably drink it in a room with a shitty brick bar and a garish red and purple carpet, packed with tattooed blokes who are all chain smoking while watching racing on a black and while telly.

1972 Watneys Red
pale malt 5.75 lb 76.67%
lightly roasted barley 400 L 0.25 lb 3.33%
No. 2 invert sugar 1.50 lb 20.00%
Fuggles 105 min 0.75 oz
Fuggles 60 min 0.75 oz
Goldings 15 min 0.75 oz
OG 1037.1
FG 1009.5
ABV 3.65
Apparent attenuation 74.39%
IBU 30
SRM 9
Mash at 158º F
Sparge at 175º F
Boil time 105 minutes
pitching temp 60º F
Yeast WLP023 Burton Ale

The above is taken from my recipe Let's Brew! Please buy a copy.


Saturday, 21 December 2019

Let's Brew - 1965 Whitbread W (Trophy)

Treateroonie time. A classic Big Six Bitter from the 1960s. A beer which, I'm sure even by this date, was often served in evil keg form.

Whitbread’s trick in getting a national Ordinary Bitter brand, was to simply rename the appropriate beer in the range of every brewery they took over Trophy.

At one time there were 20-odd beers called Trophy, with quite different characters. Yet if you just looked at the TV adverts, you’d have assumed it was one uniform product across the country. “Whitbread big head Trophy Bitter, the pint that thinks it’s a quart.” That’s how the jingle went.

Whitbread took some strange turns in their later years, when they become a national group. After 1880, they were relatively unusual in not using adjuncts as most other UK breweries did. They brewed from malt and sugar, except for during WW II when they were forced, as all brewers were, to use adjuncts. In the later war years, this was flaked barley.

But as early as 1946, they dropped it again. Presumably as soon as they were allowed to. They reverted to brewing from malt and sugar alone. Flaked barley returned in 1963. But only in their Pale Ales. Though by 1965 it also featured in Best Ale and Forest Brown.


1965 Whitbread W
pale malt 7.00 lb 82.35%
crystal malt 60 L 0.50 lb 5.88%
flaked barley 1.00 lb 11.76%
Fuggles 75 min 0.75 oz
Goldings 40 min 0.75 oz
Goldings 20 min 0.75 oz
Goldings dry hops 0.25 oz
OG 1036.5
FG 1007
ABV 3.90
Apparent attenuation 80.82%
IBU 29
SRM 6
Mash at 148º F
Sparge at 165º F
Boil time 75 minutes
pitching temp 64º F
Yeast Wyeast 1099 Whitbread ale

The above recipe is from my overly detailed look at post-war UK brewing, Austerity!

http://www.lulu.com/content/paperback-book/austerity/23181344